Newburgh letter
On May 22, 1782, the Newburgh letter was sent to George Washington who was camped at Newburgh, New York; written for the army officers by Colonel Lewis Nicola, it proposed that Washington should become the King of the United States.[1] Washington reacted very strongly against the suggestion, and was greatly troubled by it.[2]
The letter could in many ways have been a turning point in American history. Nicola's proposal, while never fully formed, would not be suggesting tyranny (he rejected how others equated monarchy and tyranny) but instead a constitutional monarchy. The letter can be considered part of the Newburgh Conspiracy and the first grievance that Nicola highlights is the lack of adequate payment for troops.
Nicola used the first part of the letter to describe a financial hardship that both he and many of the men under his command were facing - their lack of pay. Most of the Army had been waiting for months—some even for years—for their pay from Congress. The justification for this was found in the Articles of Confederation, which allowed the Continental Congress to set up an army in time of war, but was not obligated to levy taxes. The right to collect taxes was reserved for the respective states, most of which were unable to afford the maintenance of an army. Nicola believed that this condition was the manifested weakness of a republic, writing, "When the benefits of a mixed government are pointed out and duly considered, will be examined readily adopted [...]".[3]
Alluding to the person on Nicola wrote Washington, it is well recognized that "The same abilities which have led us, through difficulties apparently insurmountable by human power, to victory and glory, those qualities that have merited and universal esteem and veneration Obtained the of an army, would be most likely to conduct and direct us in the smoother paths of peace.[3]
After concluding his criticism of the republican form of government, Nicola suggested that Washington take the title of king. Recognizing that the terms "tyranny" and "monarchy" had too many negative connotations at the time, Nicola advised using an alternative title in the near future, "[...] But if all other things were once adjusted I believe strong argument might be produced for admitting the title of king, Which I conceive would be attended with some material advantages.[3]
Washington was aware that some feared he aspired to be an "American Cromwell". In his reply, dated the same day he gave Nicola a decidedly clear answer, Washington said, "No incident in the course of the war in me triggers painful feelings as your message, that such ideas are circulating in the army, as you expressed it".[4] Washington mentioned that he knew not what part of his conduct could have given rise to such a petition, which he thought a "calamity" facing the United States.[4] David Humphreys and Jonathan Trumbull,[4] two of Washington's aides, certified in a rare precautionary measure that proved the document to be genuine.
Nicola responded contritely to the harsh rejection of his complaints and suggestions. On May 23 he replied to Washington, expressing his sadness at displeasing Washington, and claiming that "nothing had ever affected" him so greatly as his "reproof."[4] Furthermore, Nicola asked Washington to evaluate every mistake that he had committed.[5] Washington's answer to this and two other letters of apology written by Nicola on May 24 and 28 are not known. However, the relationship between Nicola and Washington soon returned to its prior normalcy.[6]
See also
- List of George Washington articles
- Bibliography of George Washington
- President of the United States
- Prussian scheme
References
- ^ Nicola, Lewis. "To George Washington from Lewis Nicola, 22 May 1782". Founders Online. U.S. National Archives. Retrieved 7 May 2018.
- ^ Washington, George. "To Lewis Nicola from George Washington, 22 May 1782". Founders Online. U.S. National Archives. Retrieved 7 May 2018.
- ^ a b c Nicola (1782), p. 265
- ^ a b c d Haggard (2002), p. 158
- ^ Haggard (2002), p. 159
- ^ Haggard (2002), p. 160
External links
- Image of Nicola's letter (American Memory, Library of Congress)
- Text of Washington's response
- Full text of letter to George Washington from Lewis Nicola, 22 May 1782
- Full text of Washington's unequivocal response to Lewis Nicola's proposal of a constitutional monarchy for the US, 22 May 1782
- Nicola's reaction to Washington's firm repudiation of Nicola's proposal of a constitutional monarchy for the US, 23 May 1782
- Nicola again writes to Washington to explain his motives for his first letter (and his uncertainty as to what he had written in the second one), 24 May 1782
- Nicola writes Washington again in distress over the "ill fated representation" he had sent him, 28 May 1782
- v
- t
- e
- 1st President of the United States (1789–1797)
- Senior Officer of the Army (1798–1799)
- Commander-in-Chief of the Continental Army (1775–1783)
- Delegate to the Second Continental Congress (1775)
- Delegate to the First Continental Congress (1774)
Revolutionary War
- Military career
- French and Indian War
- Washington in the American Revolution
- Commander-in-chief, Continental Army
- Aides-de-camp
- Washington's headquarters
- Boston campaign
- New York and New Jersey campaign
- Philadelphia campaign
- Battles of Saratoga
- Sullivan Expedition
- Yorktown campaign
- Culper Spy Ring
- Newburgh Conspiracy
- Newburgh letter
- Asgill Affair
- Evacuation Day
- Resignation as commander-in-chief
- Badge of Military Merit
- Washington Before Boston Medal
- Horses
- Nelson
- Blueskin
founding events
(timeline)
- 1788–89 United States presidential election
- First inauguration
- 1792 presidential election
- Second inauguration
- Title of "Mr. President"
- Cabinet of the United States
- Judiciary Act of 1789
- Oath Administration Act
- Nonintercourse Act
- Whiskey Rebellion
- Coinage Act of 1792
- Presidential Succession Act of 1792
- United States Capitol cornerstone laying
- Proclamation of Neutrality
- Jay Treaty
- Pinckney's Treaty
- Slave Trade Act of 1794
- Residence Act
- Thanksgiving Proclamation
- Farewell Address
- State of the Union Address 1790
- 1791
- 1792
- 1793
- 1796
- Cabinet
- Federal judicial appointments
public image
- Early life
- Birthplace
- Ferry Farm boyhood home
- Mount Vernon
- Fishery
- Gristmill
- Whiskey distillery
- Woodlawn Plantation
- Longfellow House–Washington's Headquarters National Historic Site
- Hasbrouck House
- First Presidential Mansion
- Second Presidential Mansion
- President's House, Philadelphia
- Germantown White House
- Custis estate
- Potomac Company
- James River and Kanawha Canal
- Mountain Road Lottery
- Congressional Gold Medal
- Thanks of Congress
- President General of the Society of the Cincinnati
- Washington College
- Washington and Lee University
- Electoral history of George Washington
- Post-presidency of George Washington
and depictions
- Washington, D.C.
- Washington state
- Washington Monument
- Mount Rushmore
- Washington's Birthday
- Purple Heart
- The Apotheosis of Washington
- Washington Monument (Boonsboro, Maryland)
- Washington Monument (Baltimore)
- George Washington (Houdon)
- plaster copy
- George Washington (Ceracchi)
- George Washington (Canova)
- George Washington (Greenough)
- George Washington (Trumbull)
- George Washington and the Revolutionary War Door
- Revolutionary War Door
- Washington Crossing the Delaware
- The Passage of the Delaware
- General George Washington at Trenton
- Washington at Verplanck's Point
- General George Washington Resigning His Commission
- Surrender of Lord Cornwallis
- Unfinished portrait
- Lansdowne portrait
- The Washington Family portrait
- Washington at Princeton paintings
- George Washington Taking the Salute at Trenton
- Reception at Trenton painting
- Statues
- Trenton Battle Monument
- Princeton Battle Monument
- Point of View sculpture
- George Washington on Horseback
- Austin statue
- Baltimore statue
- Boston statue
- Mexico City statue
- Morristown statue
- Newark statue
- New York City statue
- Wall Street statue
- Paris statue
- Perth Amboy statue
- Philadelphia statue
- Portland statue
- Washington, D.C. statue
- West Point monument
- George Washington University
- Washington University in St. Louis
- Washington Masonic National Memorial
- George Washington Memorial Parkway
- George Washington Bridge
- Washington and Jefferson National Forests
- Washington Square Park
- U.S. Postage stamps
- Currency
- Mount Washington
- Cultural depictions
- George Washington (1984 miniseries
- 1986 sequel)
- A More Perfect Union (1989 film)
- The Crossing (2000 film)
- We Fight to Be Free (2006 film)
- Turn: Washington's Spies (2014–2017 series)
- The War that Made America (2006 miniseries)
- Washington (2020 miniseries)
- Hamilton (film)
- Bibliography
- List of articles
- Founders Online
- Founding Fathers of the United States
- Republicanism
- Federalist Party
- Virginia dynasty
- Coat of arms
- Cherry-tree anecdote
- River Farm
- Washington's Crossing
- Washington–Rochambeau Revolutionary Route
- 1751 Barbados trip
- Category
- Syng inkstand
- General of the Armies
- Conway Cabal
- American Foxhound
- American Philosophical Society
- American Revolution
- patriots
- Betsy Ross flag
- Mount Vernon Ladies' Association
- Mount Vernon replicas
- George Washington Memorial Building
- Attempted theft of Washington's skull
- Martha Washington (wife)
- John Parke Custis (stepson)
- George Washington Parke Custis (step-grandson, adopted son)
- Eleanor Parke Custis (step-granddaughter, adopted daughter)
- Augustine Washington (father)
- Mary Ball Washington (mother)
- Lawrence Washington (half-brother)
- Augustine Washington Jr. (half-brother)
- Betty Washington Lewis (sister)
- Samuel Washington (brother)
- John A. Washington (brother)
- Charles Washington (brother)
- Lawrence Washington (grandfather)
- John Washington (great-grandfather)
- George Reade (2nd great-grandfather)
- Bushrod Washington (nephew)
- Category